Company Stock and Retirement Planning Guide
Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA): How Company Stock in Your 401(k) Is Taxed When You Leave
Definition
Net unrealized appreciation (NUA) is the increase in value of employer stock held in your 401(k) above the plan's cost basis. If you take a qualifying lump-sum distribution and move the shares to a taxable account, the basis is generally taxed as ordinary income now, and the NUA is generally taxed at long-term capital gains rates when sold.
For Minnesota corporate professionals with years of company stock in a 401(k), the net unrealized appreciation 401(k) decision usually comes up at separation, retirement, or an early retirement offer. It is a one-time choice that the IRS ties to specific rules, and it comes with real trade-offs. This guide walks through how it works, how Minnesota taxes it, and how to evaluate it before you roll anything over.
The IRS Requirement
The Lump-Sum Distribution Rule
NUA treatment generally requires a lump-sum distribution. IRS Publication 575 defines this as paying out your entire balance from all of the employer's qualified plans of one kind (pension, profit-sharing, or stock bonus) within a single tax year, after a qualifying triggering event.
The whole balance has to leave the plan that year. That does not mean everything has to go to a taxable account. Many people move the employer shares to a brokerage account and roll the rest, such as mutual funds or cash, into an IRA in the same year.
Order and timing matter. If you take partial distributions after a triggering event without finishing the lump sum in that tax year, you may not qualify for NUA treatment until the next triggering event. Confirm the details with your plan administrator and tax professional before you request any distribution.
Source: IRS Publication 575, accessed November 21, 2026.
The Four Triggering Events
Per IRS Publication 575, a lump-sum distribution has to be paid because of one of these events:
Separation From Service
Leaving your employer through retirement, resignation, layoff, or an early retirement package. This trigger applies to employees, not self-employed participants.
Reaching Age 59½
This can apply while you are still working, if your plan allows in-service distributions.
Death
Beneficiaries may be able to elect NUA treatment on inherited employer shares.
Total and Permanent Disability
Under Publication 575, this trigger applies to self-employed participants.
How the Tax Works
NUA Tax Treatment, Layer by Layer
With NUA, a single block of company stock is split into up to three tax layers. Each layer is taxed at a different time and under different rules.
01
Cost Basis: Ordinary Income Now
The plan's cost basis in the shares is generally included in your ordinary income in the year of distribution. If you are under 59½ and no exception applies, the additional tax on early distributions may also apply to this taxable amount.
02
NUA: Long-Term Gain When Sold
The appreciation above basis is generally not taxed at distribution. When you sell, gain up to the NUA amount is treated as long-term capital gain, no matter how long you hold the shares afterward.
03
Later Growth: Your Holding Period
Gain beyond the NUA is short-term or long-term depending on how long you hold the shares after distribution. IRS Notice 98-24 confirms this.
Sources: IRS Publication 575; IRS Notice 98-24. Accessed November 21, 2026.
The Minnesota Angle
How Minnesota Taxes NUA
Most national NUA articles focus on federal rates. For Minnesota residents, the state side changes the math. According to the Minnesota House Research Department, Minnesota taxes net capital gains at the same graduated rates as other income. There is no lower state rate for long-term gains.
In practice, Minnesota taxes the basis as ordinary income in the year of distribution, and it also taxes the NUA as ordinary income when you sell. The difference between ordinary and capital gains rates exists mainly at the federal level. Minnesota's role is mostly about when the income shows up and which bracket it lands in.
That is why spreading sales across tax years, coordinating with other retirement income, and planning around years with less earned income can affect the state result. For the full picture, see our guide to Minnesota state taxes on retirement income.
2026 Minnesota Income Tax Rates
4
Graduated brackets
9.85%
Top 2026 state rate
According to the Minnesota Department of Revenue, the 2026 rates are 5.35%, 6.80%, 7.85%, and 9.85%. Income thresholds vary by filing status.
Source: Minnesota Department of Revenue, 2026 Rates and Brackets, accessed November 21, 2026.
Side-by-Side
NUA Distribution vs. Full IRA Rollover vs. Partial NUA
None of these paths is right for everyone. The table compares the general tax treatment and trade-offs of each one. How it plays out for you depends on your basis, your brackets, and your other assets.
| Factor | NUA Distribution (All Shares) | Full IRA Rollover | Partial NUA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax at distribution | Basis taxed as ordinary income (federal and Minnesota) | Generally none if completed as a direct rollover | Basis taxed only on the shares moved to a taxable account |
| Federal tax on appreciation | NUA taxed at long-term capital gains rates when sold | All IRA withdrawals taxed as ordinary income | Mixed: capital gains on NUA shares, ordinary income on IRA withdrawals |
| Minnesota tax on appreciation | Taxed at ordinary state rates when sold | Taxed at ordinary state rates when withdrawn | Ordinary state rates on both portions |
| Control over timing | You choose when to sell. Required distributions do not apply in a taxable account. | Required minimum distribution rules apply later | Flexible on the taxable shares. RMD rules apply to the IRA portion. |
| Concentration risk | Can stay high if you keep the shares to defer gains | You can diversify inside the IRA without immediate tax | Reduced, depending on how much you keep in employer stock |
| At death | NUA is generally treated as income in respect of a decedent and does not receive a step-up in basis | Beneficiaries generally owe ordinary income tax on withdrawals | Both treatments apply to their respective portions |
| Best evaluated when | Basis is low relative to current value and you can pay the upfront tax from other funds | Basis is high, diversification is a priority, or you have no cash to pay the upfront tax | Share lots have different basis levels, so you can choose which shares to move |
Sources: IRS Publication 575; Minnesota House Research Department. The death treatment is described in Rev. Rul. 75-125, as summarized by Tax Notes. Accessed November 21, 2026. General tax treatment only; individual results vary.
Leaving before year-end? Make the NUA decision before you sign rollover paperwork.
Once employer shares are rolled into an IRA, NUA treatment on those shares is generally no longer available. We can review your plan statement and cost basis with you first.
Benefits and Trade-Offs
What NUA Can and Cannot Do
NUA can turn part of a retirement account balance into income taxed at federal long-term capital gains rates instead of ordinary rates. Each potential benefit comes with a cost or risk, so it helps to weigh them side by side.
If company stock makes up a large share of your net worth, read our guide to managing a concentrated stock position before you decide to keep shares in order to defer the gain.
Lower Federal Rates on Appreciation
Trade-off: You pay ordinary income tax on the basis now, which may push you into a higher bracket in the distribution year. Minnesota does not offer a lower capital gains rate.
Flexibility on When to Sell
Trade-off: Holding a single stock to spread out gains keeps you exposed to company-specific risk. The share price can fall, and that can erase the tax advantage you were preserving.
Fewer Assets Subject to RMDs Later
Trade-off: Shares in a taxable account lose the tax-deferred growth an IRA provides. Dividends and later gains are taxed as they occur.
Capital Gains Treatment for Heirs
Trade-off: The NUA amount generally does not receive a step-up in basis at death. If leaving the shares to heirs is part of your plan, it should be coordinated with estate planning.
Before You Decide
NUA Decision Checklist
Collect these answers before you request a distribution. If any of them is unclear, it is worth getting help first.
Request a Company Stock and NUA Review
This is a no-cost first conversation with no obligation. We look at your plan statement and cost basis, then explain how each distribution path would generally be taxed in your situation.
Minnesota Employer Plans
Where NUA Questions Come Up Most
Many large Minnesota employers let participants hold company stock in their 401(k) or savings plan. Plan rules on in-kind distributions, lot tracking, and timing differ from one employer to the next. Our employer guides cover the plan-specific details:
3M Pension and NUA Strategy
Pension elections and company stock decisions for 3M professionals.
Medtronic Executive Benefits
Coordinating equity, deferred compensation, and retirement plan assets.
UnitedHealth Group 401(k) Match
The match, employer stock, and rollover timing for UnitedHealth Group employees.
U.S. Bank 401(k) and Pension
Plan features and distribution choices for U.S. Bancorp professionals.
FAQ
Net Unrealized Appreciation Questions
Is NUA Worth It?
It depends on your situation. NUA is most often worth a closer look when the plan's cost basis is low compared with the shares' current value, when you can pay the upfront tax on the basis from other funds, and when you have a plan to manage concentration risk. When basis is high, when you would have to sell shares to pay the tax, or when diversification is the priority, a full IRA rollover may be the better fit. Minnesota taxes capital gains at ordinary rates, so the potential advantage is mainly federal.
Do You Pay Taxes When Selling Stock in a 401(k)?
No. Selling stock inside a 401(k) generally does not create a taxable event, because tax applies when money is distributed from the plan. The catch is that selling employer shares inside the plan before you leave gives up any potential NUA treatment on those shares. Withdrawals of the sale proceeds would later be taxed as ordinary income.
How Do You Take Advantage of Net Unrealized Appreciation?
After a qualifying triggering event, request a lump-sum distribution of your entire plan balance within one tax year. Move the employer shares in kind to a taxable brokerage account and roll any remaining assets to an IRA if you choose. Before you start, confirm the cost basis, the plan's procedures, and the tax impact with your plan administrator and a tax professional.
Can I Use NUA If I Already Rolled My 401(k) Into an IRA?
Generally no. NUA treatment applies to employer securities distributed from the qualified plan. Once the shares are rolled into an IRA, withdrawals from the IRA are generally taxed as ordinary income. That is why the review should happen before any rollover paperwork is submitted.
Does Minnesota Give a Lower Rate on NUA?
No. According to the Minnesota House Research Department, Minnesota includes net capital gains in taxable income at the same graduated rates as other income. The basis is taxed by Minnesota in the distribution year, and the NUA is taxed when the shares are sold.
Our Approach
Strategy Before the Rollover Form
At New Horizons Boutique Financial Services, the NUA question is one part of a larger plan. We look at your investments, taxes, retirement income, cash flow, and estate goals before we make any recommendation. We take on a limited number of clients so that each person works directly with their advisor, and we revisit the strategy at quarterly reviews.
NUA decisions are often tied to choices about the order of withdrawals. See our guide to which retirement accounts to draw from first.
Lars Engman, MBA · Financial Advisor, New Horizons Boutique Financial Services
Alec Engman, B.S. Economics, University of Minnesota · Financial Advisor
Garrett Engman, AIF® · Financial Advisor
Keep Reading
- Should you take an early retirement package? Severance, the Rule of 55, and timing
- Ways to reduce risk in a concentrated stock position
- How Minnesota taxes 401(k), IRA, pension, and Social Security income
- Planning for stock options and equity compensation in Minnesota
Primary sources: IRS Publication 575; IRS Notice 98-24; Minnesota Department of Revenue; Minnesota House Research Department. All accessed November 21, 2026.
Next Step
Review Your Company Stock Before It Leaves the Plan
If you are separating from a Minnesota employer, considering an early retirement offer, or just want to see where you stand, the first meeting is free and carries no pressure to continue. We will go through your plan statement, cost basis, and options with you.
info@newhorizonsbfs.com · 8647 Eagle Point Blvd. Suite #1, Minnesota